What Is the Structure of the E₄ Intermediate in Nitrogenase?

Nitrogenase is the only enzyme that can cleave the strong triple bond in N₂. The active site contains a complicated MoFe₇S₉C cluster. It is believed that it needs to accept four protons and electrons, forming the E₄ state, before it can bind N₂. However, there is no consensus on the atomic structure of the E₄ state. Experimental studies indicate that it should contain two hydride ions bridging two pairs of Fe ions, and it has been suggested that both hydride ions as well as the two protons bind on the same face of the cluster. On the other hand, density functional theory (DFT) studies have indicated that it is energetically more favorable with either three hydride ions or with a triply protonated carbide ion, depending on the DFT functional. We have performed a systematic combined quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical (QM/MM) study of possible E₄ states with two bridging hydride ions. Our calculations suggest that the most favorable structure has hydride ions bridging the Fe2/6 and Fe3/7 ion pairs. In fact, such structures are 14 kJ/mol more stable than structures with three hydride ions, showing that pure DFT functionals give energetically most favorable structures in agreement with experiments. An important reason for this finding is that we have identified a new type of broken-symmetry state that involves only two Fe ions with minority spin, in contrast to the previously studied states with three Fe ions with minority spin. The energetically best structures have the two hydride ions on different faces of the FeMo cluster, whereas better agreement with ENDOR data is obtained if they are on the same face; such structures are only 6-22 kJ/mol less stable.