Modifying Accelerometer Cut-Points Affects Criterion Validity in Simulated Free-Living for Adolescents and Adults

Purpose: To assess changes in criterion validity when modifying cut-points for use in different epoch lengths. Method: Simulated free-living data came from 42 adolescents (2-hr each) and 29 adults (6-hr each) wearing a hip-worn accelerometer and portable indirect calorimeter (Cosmed K4b²). K4b² data were classified as sedentary behavior (SB), light physical activity (LPA), or moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (MVPA), and compared to estimates from accelerometer data processed with three youth and three adult cut-points in six epoch lengths (1, 5, 10, 15, 30, and 60-s). A cut-point of 100 counts per minute was used for all SB estimates. Results: For both adolescents and adults, SB estimates in all but 60-s epochs were significantly higher than the criterion, by 18.4%-78.4% (all p < .02). CPS had varied effects on youth LPA, ranging from favorable effects for one cut-point (1.9% underestimation in 1-s epochs, versus 40.2% overestimation in the originally-calibrated epoch length; p < .01 and p = .91, respectively) to unfavorable effects for another (41.8% underestimation in 1-s epochs, versus 9.8% underestimation in the originally-calibrated epoch length; p < .01 and p = .39, respectively). Adult LPA estimates in 30-s or 60-s epochs were closest to the criterion (within 5.2%-37.3%, p = .0001-0.49). Youth MVPA estimates in 60-s epochs were closest to the criterion (within 9.5%-53.2%, all p < .05), whereas adult MVPA estimates in 1-s epochs were closest to the criterion (within 6.6%-34.2%, p = .02-0.59). Conclusion: Cut-point modification is not universally beneficial, and thus it is not recommended.