In vivo and in vitro evidence of cell recovery from complement attack in rheumatoid synovium

In the previous article we have demonstrated, by quantifying terminal complement complexes in synovial fluid, that membrane attack complex activation occurs in the joint in rheumatoid arthritis. Here we describe evidence of synoviocyte resistance to complement attack in vivo and in vitro. Gel filtration of terminal complement complex positive synovial fluid on Sepharose 2B revealed two forms of terminal complement complex: one form, eluting coincident with the column void, did not react with antibody to the fluid-phase inhibitor of complement membrane attack, the S-protein, suggesting that it was composed of membrane attack complexes, the other form, eluting in the included volume, did react with the anti-S-protein antibody, suggesting that it was composed of functionally inactive SC5b-9 complexes. The high molecular weight membrane attack complex peak was demonstrated by electron microscopy to be composed of membrane vesicles bearing many lesions having the typical appearance of complement membrane attack complexes. No discernible structures were present in the lower molecular weight peak. The effects of non-lethal complement membrane attack on human synoviocytes in culture were also investigated. Synoviocytes were relatively resistant to killing by autologous complement, end-point lysis of optimally antibody-sensitized cells never exceeding 60% even at a serum dilution of 1:2. At serum dilutions of 1:20 or less, no significant cell killing occurred despite a high degree of membrane attack pathway activation, suggesting the existence of resistance and recovery mechanisms. Non-lethal complement membrane attack stimulated the release of toxic reactive oxygen metabolites from synoviocytes. These, and other reactive species released during non-lethal complement attack in vivo, may play a significant role in the pathogenesis of rheumatoid arthritis.