Lack of fine-tuned egg rejection adjustment in barn swallows with variable local abundance of common cuckoos

Tracking variation in hosts' responses to parasitism across space in a metapopulation is critical to assess the current status of parasitism/anti-parasitism in a host-parasite system, which is also helpful to infer its coevolutionary history. The barn swallow Hirundo rustica is a tractable bird species to understand potential fine-tuned adaptations to avian brood parasitism across small geographic scales, both in the context of variation in its foreign-egg rejection pattern, and its widespread distribution in cuckoo-free urban areas and in cuckoo-present rural habitats, including reedbeds. Here we tested whether variation in co-occurrence between the host and its rare brood parasite, the common cuckoo Cuculus canorus (i.e., high level of co-occurrence in reed habitats, low in town habitats) at the metapopulation level predicts patterns of antiparasitic egg rejection behaviors in barn swallows in response to different types of model and natural eggs. Contrary to our predictions, higher parasite detectability in the reed habitat did not translate into higher parasitism rate and, in turn, we also found similarly low egg rejection rates across both sampled habitat types. These patterns implied a lack of fine-tuned increase of egg rejection rate in the reed-breeding population of barn swallows as a response to the increased perceived cuckoo encounter rate, perhaps because higher potential parasitism threat did not transfer into greater actual parasitism rate. It remains to be assessed whether the lack of small-scale geographic variation in barn swallows' egg rejection rates persists because this species responds to selection by parasitism as a spatially contiguous evolutionary unit.