Parallel comparison of three methodologies for measuring functional C1-inhibitor in Hereditary angioedema patients

Hereditary angioedema (HAE) types I and II are characterized by functional C1 inhibitor (fC1-INH) deficiency which results in bradykinin overproduction. Sensitive, specific and robust methods to quantitate fC1-INH in human samples are required for diagnosing HAE and/or to measure pharmacodynamic activity of C1-INH drugs in clinical studies. To date, three methods have been reported in literature to measure fC1-INH: conventional chromogenic assay measuring residual C1-esterase activity, and immunoassays based on functional binding to either activated complement C1s or Factor XIIa/kallikrein. We used three qualified/validated fit-for purpose methods to quantitate fC1-INH in human plasma and to conduct a parallel comparison for diagnostic purposes and as a read-out for pharmacodynamic activity. Sensitivity and specificity were determined from the Receiver Operator Characteristics (ROC) curve analysis of the three fC1-INH methods through testing of fifty healthy control vs. HAE plasma samples. fC1-INH profile of fifteen HAE subjects, who underwent different treatment regimen in a cross-over Shire C1-INH clinical study, was analyzed in these three methods in parallel. A correlation analysis performed between these methods using data generated from clinical samples showed that profiles obtained from different fC1-INH methods matched for individual HAE subjects. Our findings suggest that functional binding immunoassay methods serve as reliable alternates for conventional chromogenic method to quantitate fC1-INH in human plasma samples with a better dynamic range of detection and ease of use. Of the two immunoassays used in this study, FXIIa-binding method gave better sensitivity, specificity, and correlation to the chromogenic method as a diagnostic method to distinguish HAE samples from healthy controls.