Theory of the perceived motion direction of equal-spatial-frequency plaid stimuli

At an early stage, 3 different systems independently extract visual motion information from visual inputs. At later stages, these systems combine their outputs. Here, we consider a much studied (>650 publications) class of visual stimuli, plaids, which are combinations of 2 sine waves. Currently, there is no quantitative theory that can account for the perceived motion of plaids. We consider only perceived plaid direction, not speed, and obtain a large set of data exploring the various dimensions in which same-spatial-frequency plaids differ. We find that only 2 of the 3 motion systems are active in plaid processing, and that plaids with temporal frequencies 10 Hz or greater typically stimulate only the first-order motion system, which combines the plaid components by vector summation: Each plaid component is represented by a contrast-strength vector whose length is contrast-squared times a factor representing the relative effectiveness of that component's temporal frequency. The third-order system, which becomes primary at low temporal frequencies, also represents a plaid as 2 vectors that sum according to their contrast strength: a pure plaid in which both components have equal contrast and a residual sine wave. Second-order motion is irrelevant for these plaids. These principles enable a contrast-strength-vector summation theory for the responses of the first-order and third-order motion systems. With zero parameters estimated from the data, the theory captures the essence of the full range of the plaid data and supports the counterintuitive hypothesis that motion direction is processed independently of speed at early stages of visual processing. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2020 APA, all rights reserved).