Three-dimensional genome architectural CCCTC-binding factor makes choice in duplicated enhancers at Pcdhα locus

During development, gene expression is spatiotemporally regulated by long-distance chromatin interactions between distal enhancers and target promoters. However, how specificity of the interactions between enhancers and promoters is achieved remains largely unknown. As there are far more enhancers than promoters in mammalian genomes, the complexities of enhancer choice during gene regulation remain obscure. CTCF, the CCCTC-binding factor that directionally binds to a vast range of genomic sites known as CBSs (CTCF-binding sites), mediates oriented chromatin looping between a substantial set of distal enhancers and target promoters. To investigate mechanisms by which CTCF engages in enhancer choice, we used CRISPR/Cas9-based DNA-fragment editing to duplicate CBS-containing enhancers and promoters in the native genomic locus of the clustered Pcdhα genes. We found that the promoter is regulated by the proximal one among duplicated enhancers and that this choice is dependent on CTCF-mediated directional enhancer-promoter looping. In addition, gene expression is unaltered upon the switch of enhancers. Moreover, after promoter duplication, only the proximal promoter is chosen by CTCF-mediated directional chromatin looping to contact with the distal enhancer. Finally, we demonstrated that both enhancer activation and chromatin looping with the promoter are essential for gene expression. These findings have important implications regarding the role of CTCF in specific interactions between enhancers and promoters as well as developmental regulation of gene expression by enhancer switching.