The process of implementing child mortality reviews in low- and middle-income countries: a narrative systematic...

This review aims to describe the processes that have been used to implement child mortality reviews in LMICs and to identify the facilitators and barriers to their implementation and impact. This will help to inform healthcare professionals and managers planning to implement a child mortality review in their setting.

MEDLINE and Embase databases were searched for papers published between January 1996 and April 2019. Studies reporting the implementation of a child mortality review process in LMICs were considered eligible. A narrative approach was used to describe the stages in the audit process outlined in the WHO 'Operational guide for facility-based audit and review of paediatric mortality' which were completed, and to synthesise the barriers and facilitators to implementation and impact of the child mortality review process.

From 776 potentially relevant articles, seven studies were included. In six studies, problems contributing to child deaths and possible solutions were identified, in four, these solutions were implemented, and in one, this implementation was monitored. Key factors influencing implementation and impact were attendance at meetings, use of a blame-free approach, allocating adequate human and financial resources to make changes, and level of engagement from leadership.

Despite the common use of mortality reviews in paediatric departments, there are few studies published on this topic. The transition from identifying problems and solutions to implementing and monitoring action plans appears to be the most difficult aspect of the process, which requires commitment of adequate resources and strong leadership.