Research Techniques Made Simple: Randomized Controlled Trials for Topical Drugs in Dermatology: When and How Should...

Topical drugs are often used as first-line treatment for dermatological conditions. Depending on the disease and the drug, three main designs can be used for randomized controlled trials assessing topical drugs: the classical individual parallel design, the cluster randomized design, and designs allowing within-individual comparisons, including the cross-over design (in which patients are randomized to a sequence of interventions) and the within-person design (also called the split-body design). Within-person design can be used to compare different drugs concomitantly in the same patient. Randomization does not concern patients but rather lesions or body sites within patients, and the drugs to be compared are applied to the different lesions (or sites). This design considerably reduces interobservation variability, and thus, the number of patients to be included in the trial (sample size). However, this design has major methodological constraints, especially the need to resolve the problem of a possible carry-across effect. First, we describe the specificities of randomized controlled trials evaluating a topical drug. Second, we present the different designs available and discuss the methodological points that should be considered, especially for a within-person design. Finally, we compare the relevance of the within-person design with that of other trial designs by considering three different scenarios.