Impact of High-intensity Zones on Their Corresponding Lumbar Spine Segments: A Propensity Score-matched Analysis

Retrospective radiographic study.

The aim of this study was to compare disks with and without high-intensity zones (HIZ) to understand the impact of an HIZ on the stability of corresponding lumbar spinal segments.

Previous studies have established a relationship between back pain and the presence of HIZ on T2-weighted images of magnetic resonance imaging. These previous studies, however, used either plain radiographs or static (neutral position) magnetic resonance imaging to assess their chosen variables.

We retrospectively reviewed 140 consecutive patients with MR images taken in weight-bearing neutral, flexion, and extension positions. We separated segments into those with HIZ and without HIZ and assessed the grade of disk degeneration for each segment. Subsequently, a matched control group was selected from the segments without HIZ. Multiple factors were compared in a univariate analysis. A multinomial logistic regression analysis was conducted to assess the association between angular range of motion (ROM) >10 degrees and translational motion >2 mm with multiple independent variables.

Upon assessment of the 700 lumbar segments, 70 (10%) segments had an HIZ and 68 patients had a single HIZ. On univariate analysis, the presence of an HIZ was not found to be significantly associated with degree of fatty muscle degeneration (P=0.969), muscle volume (P=0.646), degree of facet joint osteoarthritis (P=0.706), intervertebral disk height (P=0.077), Modic change (P=0.951), lower endplate shape (P=0.702), upper endplate shape (P=0.655), or degree of disk degeneration (P=0.607). Multifactorial analysis showed that none of the independent variables significantly correlated with angular ROM >10 degrees. For translational motion, the only significant correlation was the Goutallier classification (P=0.017).

The presence of HIZ did not significantly affect spinal stability as measured by angular ROM and translational motion and was not associated with significant changes in several quantitative measurements of spine pathology.