Possibility of Autonomous Estimation of Shiba Goat's Estrus and Non-Estrus Behavior by Machine Learning Methods

Mammalian behavior is typically monitored by observation. However, direct observation requires a substantial amount of effort and time, if the number of mammals to be observed is sufficiently large or if the observation is conducted for a prolonged period. In this study, machine learning methods as hidden Markov models (HMMs), random forests, support vector machines (SVMs), and neural networks, were applied to detect and estimate whether a goat is in estrus based on the goat's behavior; thus, the adequacy of the method was verified. Goat's tracking data was obtained using a video tracking system and used to estimate whether they, which are in "estrus" or "non-estrus", were in either states: "approaching the male", or "standing near the male". Totally, the PC of random forest seems to be the highest. However, The percentage concordance (PC) value besides the goats whose data were used for training data sets is relatively low. It is suggested that random forest tend to over-fit to training data. Besides random forest, the PC of HMMs and SVMs is high. However, considering the calculation time and HMM's advantage in that it is a time series model, HMM is better method. The PC of neural network is totally low, however, if the more goat's data were acquired, neural network would be an adequate method for estimation.