Mechanistic modeling explains the dsRNA length-dependent activation of the RIG-I mediated immune response

In cell-intrinsic antiviral immunity, cytoplasmic receptors such as retinoic acid-inducible gene I (RIG-I) detect viral double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) and trigger a signaling cascade activating the interferon (IFN) system. This leads to the transcription of hundreds of interferon-stimulated genes (ISGs) with a wide range of antiviral effects. This recognition of dsRNA not only has to be very specific to discriminate foreign from self but also highly sensitive to detect even very low numbers of pathogenic dsRNA molecules. Previous work indicated an influence of the dsRNA length on the binding behavior of RIG-I and its potential to elicit antiviral signaling. However, the molecular mechanisms behind the binding process are still under debate. We compare two hypothesized RIG-I binding mechanisms by translating them into mathematical models and analyzing their potential to describe published experimental data. The models consider the length of the dsRNA as well as known RIG-I binding motifs and describe RIG-I pathway activation after stimulation with dsRNA. We show that internal RIG-I binding sites in addition to cooperative RIG-I oligomerization are essential to describe the experimentally observed RIG-I binding behavior and immune response activation for different dsRNA lengths and concentrations. The combination of RIG-I binding to internal sites on the dsRNA and cooperative oligomerization compensates for a lack of high-affinity binding motifs and triggers a strong antiviral response for long dsRNAs. Model analysis reveals dsRNA length-dependency as a potential mechanism to discriminate between different types of dsRNAs: It allows for sensitive detection of small numbers of long dsRNAs, a typical by-product of viral replication, while ensuring tolerance against non-harming small dsRNAs.