Diversity and species identity effects on fine root productivity and turnover in a species-rich temperate...

We investigated the evidence of belowground overyielding in a species-rich temperate broad-leaved forest with an ingrowth core study in 100 plots containing five common tree species (beech, lime, maple, hornbeam, ash) in mono-specific and 2-species or 3-species combinations. This design allowed separating diversity and species identity effects on root dynamics in a mature forest with long continuity. Fine root productivity was not significantly different between mono-specific and 2- or 3-species plots, whereas fine root turnover was significantly higher in the mixed than the mono-specific plots. Species identity effects on root turnover and root productivity were important. Ash achieved in the mixtures the highest fine root productivity and root turnover of all species; it is an apparent key species in this forest. Evidence in support of a diversity effect on fine root productivity and turnover was weak, however.