Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jul 25, 2026

Transtubular Endoscopic Posterolateral Decompression for L5-S1 Lumbar Lateral Disc Herniation
Published on: October 14, 2022
Differentiating epidural fibrosis from disc herniation on contrast-enhanced and unenhanced MRI in the postoperative
Zita Passavanti1,2, Sebastian Leschka3,4, Simon Wildermuth3,4
1Division of Radiology and Nuclear Medicine, Kantonsspital St. Gallen, Rorschacherstrasse 95, CH 9007, St. Gallen, Switzerland. Zita.Passavanti@kssg.ch.
Objective:
To determine diagnostic confidence and inter-observer/intra-observer agreement in differentiating epidural fibrosis from disc herniation and lumbar spinal stenosis parameters on magnetic resonance images (MRI) in postoperative lumbar spines with (Gad-MRI) and without (unenhanced MRI) intravenous gadolinium-based contrast agent.
Subjects And Methods:
N = 124 lumbar spine MRI examinations of four groups were included: 1-6 months, 7-18 months, 19-36 months, more than 37 months between lumbar spine surgery and imaging. Two radiologists evaluated Gad-MRI and unenhanced MRI: diagnostic confidence was determined as confident or unconfident. Inter-observer and intra-observer agreement were assessed in differentiating epidural fibrosis from disc herniation and for lumbar spinal stenosis parameters on MRI. Fisher's exact test and Cohen's kappa served for statistics.
Results:
Diagnostic confidence in differentiating epidural fibrosis from disc herniation was significantly higher on Gad-MR images compared with unenhanced MRI at 1-18 months for observer 1 and at 1-6 months postoperatively for observer 2 (p values: 0.01-0.025). Inter-observer agreement at 1-6 months postoperatively for identification of epidural fibrosis was higher on Gad-MRI (kappa values: 0.53 versus 0.24). Inter-observer and intra-observer agreement for identification of disc herniation and for assessment of lumbar spinal stenosis parameters revealed inconsistent data, without a trend for higher inter-observer or intra-observer agreement on Gad-MRI compared with unenhanced MRI (kappa values: 0.17-0.75).
Conclusion:
Gad-MR images compared with unenhanced MRI improved diagnostic confidence and agreement in differentiating epidural fibrosis from disc herniation for both observers in the first 6 months and for one observer in the first 18 months after lumbar spine surgery. After 18 months, Gad-MR images compared with unenhanced MRI did neither improve confidence nor agreement.
Insights
Gadolinium-enhanced MRI (Gad-MRI) significantly improves diagnostic confidence in differentiating epidural fibrosis from disc herniation in the early months after lumbar spine surgery. However, this benefit diminishes after 18 months post-surgery.
Area of Science:
- Radiology
- Medical Imaging
- Neurosurgery
Background:
- Postoperative complications after lumbar spine surgery, such as epidural fibrosis and recurrent disc herniation, can be challenging to differentiate using conventional MRI.
- Gadolinium-based contrast agents (Gad-MRI) may enhance the visualization of these pathologies.
Purpose of the Study:
- To compare the diagnostic confidence and inter-observer/intra-observer agreement of Gad-MRI versus unenhanced MRI in differentiating epidural fibrosis from disc herniation and assessing lumbar spinal stenosis parameters in postoperative lumbar spines.
- To evaluate the impact of time elapsed since surgery on the effectiveness of Gad-MRI.
Main Methods:
- 124 lumbar spine MRI examinations from patients at varying intervals (1-6, 7-18, 19-36, >37 months) post-surgery were reviewed.
- Two radiologists assessed both Gad-MRI and unenhanced MRI scans, evaluating diagnostic confidence and agreement for specific findings.
- Statistical analysis included Fisher's exact test and Cohen's kappa to assess agreement.
Main Results:
- Diagnostic confidence in differentiating epidural fibrosis from disc herniation was significantly higher with Gad-MRI compared to unenhanced MRI within the first 18 months post-surgery.
- Inter-observer agreement for epidural fibrosis identification was notably better with Gad-MRI in the early postoperative period (1-6 months).
- Agreement for disc herniation and lumbar spinal stenosis assessment showed inconsistent results, with no clear advantage for Gad-MRI over unenhanced MRI after 18 months.
Conclusions:
- Gad-MRI enhances diagnostic confidence and agreement for differentiating epidural fibrosis from disc herniation in the initial 6-18 months following lumbar spine surgery.
- The diagnostic utility of Gad-MRI in this context appears limited beyond 18 months postoperatively.
- Unenhanced MRI may suffice for evaluating disc herniation and spinal stenosis beyond the early postoperative period.
Related Concept Videos
Herniated Intervertebral Disc l: Introduction
Degenerative Disc Disease I: Introduction
Degenerative Disc Disease ll: Pathophysiology

