Incorporating ToxCast™ data into naphthalene human health risk assessment

Chronic inhalation of naphthalene causes nasal olfactory epithelial tumors in rats and benign lung adenomas in mice. The available human data do not establish an association between naphthalene and increased respiratory cancer risk. Therefore, cancer risk assessment of naphthalene in humans depends predominantly on experimental evidence from rodents. The United States Environmental Protection Agency's (US EPA) Toxicity Forecaster (ToxCast™) database contains data from 710 in vitro assays for naphthalene, the majority of which were conducted in human cells. Of these assays, only 18 were active for naphthalene, and all were in human liver cells. No assays were active in human bronchial epithelial cells. In our analysis, all of the active naphthalene ToxCast assay data were reviewed and used to: 1) determine naphthalene human inhalation concentrations corresponding to relevant activity concentrations for all active naphthalene assays, using a physiologically based pharmacokinetic (PBPK) model; and 2) evaluate the transcriptional responses for active assays in the context of consistency with the larger naphthalene data set and proposed modes of action (MoAs) for naphthalene toxicity and carcinogenicity. The transcriptional responses in liver cells largely reflect cellular activities related to oxidative stress and chronic inflammation. Overall, the results from our analysis of the active ToxCast assays for naphthalene are consistent with conclusions from our earlier weight-of-evidence evaluation for naphthalene carcinogenesis.