Evaluating Robust Scale Transformation Methods With Multiple Outlying Common Items Under IRT True Score Equating

Item parameter estimates of a common item on a new test form may change abnormally due to reasons such as item overexposure or change of curriculum. A common item, whose change does not fit the pattern implied by the normally behaved common items, is defined as an outlier. Although improving equating accuracy, detecting and eliminating of outliers may cause a content imbalance among common items. Robust scale transformation methods have recently been proposed to solve this problem when only one outlier is present in the data, although it is not uncommon to see multiple outliers in practice. In this simulation study, the authors examined the robust scale transformation methods under conditions where there were multiple outlying common items. Results indicated that the robust scale transformation methods could reduce the influences of multiple outliers on scale transformation and equating. The robust methods performed similarly to a traditional outlier detection and elimination method in terms of reducing the influence of outliers while keeping adequate content balance.