Anisotropic properties of articular cartilage in an accelerated in vitro wear test

Many material properties of articular cartilage are anisotropic, particularly in the superficial zone where collagen fibers have a preferential direction. However, the anisotropy of cartilage wear had not been previously investigated. The objective of this study was to evaluate the anisotropy of cartilage material behavior in an in vitro wear test. The wear and coefficient of friction of bovine condylar cartilage were measured with loading in directions parallel (longitudinal) and orthogonal (transverse) to the collagen fiber orientation at the articular surface. An accelerated cartilage wear test was performed against a T316 stainless-steel plate in a solution of phosphate buffered saline with protease inhibitors. A constant load of 160 N was maintained for 14000 cycles of reciprocal sliding motion at 4 mm/s velocity and a travel distance of 18 mm in each direction. The contact pressure during the wear test was approximately 2 MPa, which is in the range of that reported in the human knee and hip joint. Wear was measured by biochemically quantifying the glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) and collagen that was released from the tissue during the wear test. Collagen damage was evaluated with collagen hybridizing peptide (CHP), while visualization of the tissue composition after the wear test was provided with histologic analysis. Results demonstrated that wear in the transverse direction released about twice as many GAGs than in the longitudinal direction, but that no significant differences were seen in the amount of collagen released from the specimens. Specimens worn in the transverse direction had a higher intensity of CHP stain than those worn in the longitudinal direction, suggesting more collagen damage from wear in the transverse direction. No anisotropy in friction was detected at any point in the wear test. Histologic and CHP images demonstrate that the GAG loss and collagen damage extended through much of the depth of the cartilage tissue, particularly for wear in the transverse direction. These results highlight distinct differences between cartilage wear and the wear of traditional engineering materials, and suggest that further study on cartilage wear is warranted. A potential clinical implication of these results is that orienting osteochondral grafts such that the direction of wear is aligned with the primary fiber direction at the articular surface may optimize the life of the graft.