Status of Simulation-Based Training in Departments of Surgery in the United States

Surgical simulation is particularly attractive because it allows training in a safe, controlled, and standardized environment. However, the status of surgical simulation among Departments of Surgery (DoS) in the United States is unknown. The objective of this study was to characterize the status of simulation-based training in DoS in the United States.

A Qualtrics online survey was sent to 177 chairs of DoS in the United States in March 2018 regarding the utilization of surgical simulation in their department. Questions in the survey were focused on simulation capacities and activities as well as chairs' perception of the value and purpose of simulation.

A total of 87 of 177 chairs responded to the survey (49% response rate). Most programs had either 20-50 trainees (42 of 87; 48%) or more than 50 trainees (37 of 87; 43%). Most chairs reported having a simulation center in their institution (85 of 87; 98%) or department (60 of 86; 70%) with a formal simulation curriculum for their trainees (83 of 87; 95%). Ninety percent (78 of 87) of DoS had protected time for simulation education for their residents, with most residents engaging in activities weekly or monthly (65 of 85; 76%). Although most chairs felt simulation improves patient safety (72 of 84; 86%) and is useful for practicing surgeons (68 of 84; 81%), only 40% reported that faculty use simulation to maintain technical skills and only 17% reported that faculty use simulation to address high complication rates.

The vast majority of the DoS in the United States have established simulation activities for their trainees. However, engagement of faculty in simulation to maintain or improve their skills remains low.