Comparison of five extraction methods for evaluating cadmium and zinc immobilization in soil

The remediation of soil contaminated with heavy metals is an ongoing environmental concern. Paddy soils contaminated with Cd and Zn were collected from around abandoned metals mines in Korea. Limestone and steel slag were mixed with the collected soil, as amendments for Cd and Zn immobilization. Sequential extraction, lettuce cultivation and five single extraction methods were carried out to assess the effects on Cd and Zn immobilization using amendments. The exchangeable fraction of Cd and Zn was decreased and Fe-Mn oxides fraction increased by stabilization using amendments. In addition, the accumulation of Cd and Zn in lettuce decreased in treated soil and indicated the Cd and Zn immobilization effect in soil by the amendments. The extractable Cd and Zn by CaCl₂ and Mehlich-3 in the untreated soils were higher than that of treated soils, whereas Cd and Zn extraction by ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA), diethylene tetramine penta-acetic acid (DTPA) and toxicity characteristic leaching procedure (TCLP) has a small or no difference between the untreated and treated soils. The extraction results by CaCl₂ and Mehlich-3 methods present reasonable results for Cd and Zn immobilization in soil than EDTA, DTPA and TCLP methods. Therefore, the choice of appropriate extraction method is very important when there is the assessment of Cd and Zn immobilization efficiency.