The power and limitations of gene expression pathway analyses toward predicting population response to environmental...

Rapid environmental changes impact the global distribution and abundance of species, highlighting the urgency to understand and predict how populations will respond. The analysis of differentially expressed genes has elucidated areas of the genome involved in adaptive divergence to past and present environmental change. Such studies however have been hampered by large numbers of differentially expressed genes and limited knowledge of how these genes work in conjunction with each other. Recent methods (broadly termed "pathway analyses") have emerged that aim to group genes that behave in a coordinated fashion to a factor of interest. These methods aid in functional annotation and uncovering biological pathways, thereby collapsing complex datasets into more manageable units, providing more nuanced understandings of both the organism-level effects of modified gene expression, and the targets of adaptive divergence. Here, we reanalyze a dataset that investigated temperature-induced changes in gene expression in marine-adapted and freshwater-adapted threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus), using Weighted Gene Co-expression Network Analysis (WGCNA) with PANTHER Gene Ontology (GO)-Slim overrepresentation and Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) pathway analysis. Six modules exhibited a conserved response and six a divergent response between marine and freshwater stickleback when acclimated to 7°C or 22°C. One divergent module showed freshwater-specific response to temperature, and the remaining divergent modules showed differences in height of reaction norms. PPARAa, a transcription factor that regulates fatty acid metabolism and has been implicated in adaptive divergence, was located in a module that had higher expression at 7°C and in freshwater stickleback. This updated methodology revealed patterns that were not found in the original publication. Although such methods hold promise toward predicting population response to environmental stressors, many limitations remain, particularly with regard to module expression representation, database resources, and cross-database integration.