Opposition-Defiance in the Second Year of Life: A Population-Based Cohort Study
Raymond H Baillargeon1, Gregory D Sward2, Kate Keenan3
1Interdisciplinary School of Health Sciences University of Ottawa.
Insights
Approximately 12.4% of toddlers exhibit frequent oppositional-defiant behaviors (ODBs). Early ODBs are strongly linked to physical aggression, but physically aggressive toddlers are a minority of those with significant opposition-defiance issues.
Area of Science:
- Child Psychology
- Developmental Epidemiology
- Behavioral Science
Background:
- Frequent oppositional-defiant behaviors (ODBs) in toddlers are uncommon, suggesting potential underlying issues.
- The "terrible twos" may mask significant opposition-defiance problems if behaviors are severe or frequent.
Purpose of the Study:
- Estimate the prevalence of frequent ODBs in the general toddler population.
- Investigate gender differences in the frequency of ODBs among toddlers.
- Examine the relationship between ODBs and physical aggression in early childhood.
Main Methods:
- Utilized data from The Québec Longitudinal Study of Child Development, a representative birth cohort.
- Employed multigroup latent class analysis to differentiate frequency levels of ODBs.
- Analyzed a cohort of 17-month-old boys and girls.
Main Results:
- 12.4% of 17-month-old toddlers exhibited ODBs on a frequent basis.
- A significant positive association was found between frequent opposition-defiance and physical aggression.
- Most physically aggressive toddlers displayed frequent ODBs, while few toddlers with significant opposition-defiance problems were frequently physically aggressive.
Conclusions:
- Frequent ODBs affect a notable minority of toddlers, warranting attention.
- Early opposition-defiance and physical aggression are closely linked in toddlers.
- Distinguishing between frequent ODBs and physical aggression is crucial for understanding early behavioral problems.
Abstract:
Recent epidemiological evidence suggests that even in the midst of the "terrible twos," frequent/severe oppositional-defiant behaviors (ODBs) are not common among toddlers and hence may be indicative of a significant opposition-defiance problem. The main objective of this study was to obtain a maximum likelihood estimate of the proportion of toddlers in the general population who are reported to exhibit ODBs on a frequent basis, and to test for gender differences therein. Data came from The Québec Longitudinal Study of Child Development, a survey of a representative birth cohort of children from the Canadian province of Québec. Multigroup latent class analysis was used to distinguish between toddlers who exhibit ODBs on a frequent basis and those who do so only occasionally or not at all. The results show that 12.4% of 17-month-old boys and girls exhibit ODBs on a frequent basis. Further, the results show a strong positive association between opposition-defiance and physical aggression early in life, with a great majority of physically aggressive toddlers exhibiting ODBs on a frequent basis. In contrast, the results show that only a minority of toddlers who may be experiencing a significant opposition-defiance problem exhibit physically aggressive behaviors on a frequent basis.
Related Concept Videos
Oppositional Defiant Disorder
Diagnostic Criteria and...
Social Foundations of Self II: The Generalized Other
Conduct Disorder
Obedience
Bullying
Secondary Motives: Affiliation Motivation and Aggression Motivation


