Evaluation of a Patient-Specific, Low-Cost, 3-Dimensional-Printed Transesophageal Echocardiography Human Heart...

Currently available 3-dimensional (3D) modeling and printing techniques allow for the creation of patient-specific models based on 3D medical imaging data. The authors hypothesized that a low-cost, patient-specific, cardiac computed tomography-based phantom, created using desktop 3D printing and casting, would have comparable image quality, accuracy, and usability to an existing commercially available echocardiographic phantom.

Blinded comparative study.

Simulation laboratory at a single academic institution.

Voluntary cardiac anesthesiologists at a single academic institution.

Stage 1 of the study consisted of an online questionnaire in which a set of basic transesophageal echocardiography (TEE) views obtained from the 3D printed phantom and commercial phantom were presented to participants, who had to identify the views and evaluate their fidelity to clinical images on a Likert scale. In stage 2, participants performed an unblinded basic TEE examination on both phantoms.

The time needed to acquire each basic view was recorded. Overall usability of the phantoms was assessed through a questionnaire. The participants could recognize most of the views. Fidelity ratings for both phantoms were similar (p < 0.05), with the exception of a midesophageal 2-chamber view that was observed better on the 3D printed phantom. The time required to obtain the views was shorter for the 3D printed phantom, although not statistically significant for most views. The overall user experience was better for the 3D phantom for all categories examined (p < 0.05).

The study suggested that a 3D-printed TEE phantom is comparable with the commercially available one with good usability.