Asymmetric response of soil methane uptake rate to land degradation and restoration: Data synthesis

Land degradation and restoration profoundly affect soil CH₄ uptake capacity in terrestrial ecosystems. However, a comprehensive assessment of the response of soil CH₄ uptake to land degradation and restoration at global scale is not available. Here, we present a global meta-analysis with a database of 228 observations from 83 studies to investigate the effects of land degradation and restoration on the capacity of soil CH₄ uptake. We found that land degradation significantly decreased the capacity of soil CH₄ uptake, except the conversion of pasture to cropland where the soil CH₄ uptake rate showed no response. In contrast, all types of land restoration significantly increased the capacity of soil CH₄ uptake. Interestingly, the response of soil CH₄ uptake rate to land degradation and restoration was asymmetric: the increased soil CH₄ uptake rate in response to the land restoration was smaller compared to the decrease in CH₄ uptake rate induced by the land degradation. The effect of land degradation on soil CH₄ uptake rate was not dependent on the time since land use change, but the CH₄ sink strength increased with the time since land restoration. The response of soil CH₄ uptake rate to both land degradation and restoration was predominantly regulated by changes in the soil water-filled pore space, soil bulk density, and pH, whereas alterations in the substrate quantity and quality had negligible effect. Additionally, the effects of land degradation and restoration on soil CH₄ uptake were strongly related to the mean annual precipitation and soil texture. Overall, our results provide novel insights for understanding of how land degradation and restoration can affect the CH₄ sink strength of upland soils, and more importantly, our findings are beneficial to take measures to enhance the potential of soil CH₄ uptake in response to global land use change.