Peer Coaching as a Form of Performance Improvement: What Surgeons Really Think

Coaching has been proposed as a potential form of continuing professional development (CPD) for surgeons. Our study aimed to elicit qualified surgeons' perceptions of peer coaching as a form of CPD and to determine the effect of demographic factors on surgeons' views.

A cross-sectional paper survey was conducted across 2 South Australian metropolitan hospitals from November 2018 to January 2019. This comprised 5 demographic questions and 6 Likert items eliciting views on peer-based coaching and was distributed at departmental unit meetings to surgical consultants and fellows. Participation was voluntary and a definition of "peer-based coaching" was provided.

Hundred and eighteen surgeons of a possible 125 (94.4% response rate) from 8 surgical specialties completed the survey with 45.4% (n = 54) having received coaching since obtaining their fellowship. The majority of participants (72.9%, n = 86) reported consultant surgeons would benefit from peer coaching and that one-on-one coaching in an individual setting would be a useful CPD activity (73.7%, n = 87). Just over half the participants (53.4%, n = 63) felt that coaching by a nonsurgeon such as a psychologist would benefit their nonoperative skills. Many participants (61.8%, n = 73) felt more inclined to participate if CPD points were awarded. Despite the support in favor of coaching, a significant percentage of participants (45.8%, n = 54) wanted further evidence of its efficacy.

There is support amongst surgeons for peer coaching and its inclusion as a form of CPD, however, many require more evidence of its benefits, thus highlighting the need for ongoing research studies, consultation and pilot coaching programs.