Carving depression at its joints? Psychometric properties of the Sydney Melancholia Prototype Index

Parker and colleagues developed the Sydney Melancholia Prototype Index (SMPI), a 24-item measure to assess a potential subtype of depression: melancholia. While research supports the validity of the measure, no study has assessed its psychometric properties. We recruited 1633 participants online, of whom 487 reported a lifetime period of depressed mood or anhedonia and were administered the SMPI. We conducted confirmatory factor analyses (CFA) of the SMPI, to assess the proposed fit of the measure. We also conducted exploratory factor analyses (EFA) to explore the structure implied by the current data. CFA did not support the hypothesized factor structure of the SMPI, no matter what structure we assumed as primary (i.e., a one factor, two factor, or bifactor model). An EFA suggested a five-factor solution wherein several items did not appear to co-vary reliably and other factors captured the severity of melancholic symptoms, negative mood reactivity, positive mood reactivity, emotionality and family relationships, and early life adversity. The SMPI may not measure a single construct. Future research should explore the longitudinal association between depression severity, contaminant symptoms, positive and negative mood reactivity, and early life experiences.