The impact of nurses' and physicians' shift change on obstetrical outcomes

To evaluate the effect around nurses' shift change and on-call physicians' shift change on obstetrical outcomes.

A retrospective study of women who had an attempt of labor in a single-medical center, January 2006-December 2017. Obstetrical outcomes were compared between the time around nurses' shift change (6:00-8:00, 14:00-16:00, and 22:00-00:00) to the rest of the day, and between the time around on-call physicians' shift change (6:00-8:00, 14:00-16:00) to the rest of the day.

32,861 women were included, 7826 deliveries occurred during nurses' shift-change, and 25,035 deliveries occurred during the rest of the day. The groups had similar general and obstetrical characteristics, with no statistical difference in cesarean delivery rate (10% vs. 9.8%, P = 0.45) (Table 1). Nurses' shift change had no measurable effect on obstetrical outcomes, including induction of labor, preterm labor, 5-min-Apgar score and cord pH value, except PPH which was less likely to occur during nurses' shift change period (3.8% vs. 4.4%, P = 0.045) (Table 2). From 32,861 deliveries, 5155 deliveries occurred during on-call physicians' shift-change, and 27,706 deliveries occurred during the rest of the day. Induction\augmentation of labor and epidural analgesia were less likely to happen during on-call physicians' shift change (34.4% vs. 38%, P < 0.0001, 59.6% vs. 61.8%, P = 0.003, respectively) (Table 3). The two groups had similar obstetrical outcomes, without statistical difference in cesarean delivery rate (10% vs. 9.8%, P = 0.63) (Table 4). Table 1 General and obstetric characteristics of women giving birth during the time of nurses shift change versus during the rest of the day Variable Change of nurses shifts (n = 7826) All other hours of the day (n = 25,035) P value Maternal age, y 30.3 ± 5.1 30.2 ± 5.2 0.09 Gestational age at birth (weeks) 39.7 ± 1.09 39.8 ± 1.10 0.55 Nulliparity 2077 (35%) 7067 (37%) 0.01 Induction\augmentation of labor 2905 (37) 9368 (38) 0.62 Epidural analgesia 4746 (61) 15,396 (62) 0.16 Neonatal birth weight, g 3340 ± 422 3330 ± 423 0.06 Data is presented as mean ± S.D or N (%) Table 2 Maternal and neonatal adverse outcomes of women giving birth during the time of nurses shift change versus during the rest of the day Variable (%) Change of nurses shifts (n = 7826) All other hours of the day (n = 25,035) P value Vacuum assisted delivery 615 (7.9) 2002 (8.0) 0.69 Cesarean delivery 788 (10) 2443 (9.8) 0.45 Postpartum hemorrhage 294 (3.8) 1089 (4.4) 0.045 Third- and fourth-degree perineal laceration 106 (1.4) 372 (1.5%) 0.51 5-min Apgar score < 7 39 (0.5) 139 (0.6) 0.65 Umbilical pH < 7.2 170 (23) 580 (23) 0.96 Prolonged second stage 190 (2.5) 559 (2.2) 0.22 Maternal and fetal composite adverse outcome* 1309 (16.7%) 4219 (16.9%) 1.00 Data is presented as N (%) *Maternal and fetal composite adverse outcome was defined as the presence of any of the following: vacuum delivery, CD, prolonged second stage, postpartum hemorrhage, third and fourth degree perineal laceration, 5-min Apgar score < 7 and umbilical cord pH < 7.2 Table 3 General and obstetric characteristics of women giving birth during the time of the on-call physicians shift change versus during the rest of the day Variable Change of physicians shifts (n = 5155) All other hours of the day (n = 27,706) P value Maternal age, years 30.3 ± 5.1 30.2 ± 5.2 0.38 Gestational age at birth (weeks) 39.8 ± 1.09 39.8 ± 1.10 0.95 Nulliparity (%) 1303 (33.4) 7841 (37)  < 0.0001 Induction\augmentation of labor (%) 1769 (34.3) 10,504 (38)  < 0.0001 Epidural analgesia (%) 3067 (59.6) 17,075 (61.8) 0.003 Neonatal birth weight (gr) 3345 ± 416 3330 ± 424 0.019 Data is presented as mean ± S.D or N (%) Table 4 Maternal and neonatal adverse outcomes of women giving birth during the time of physicians on-call shift change versus during the rest of the day Variable (%) Change of physicians shifts (n = 5155) All other hours of the day (n = 27,706) P value Vacuum assisted delivery 397 (7.7) 2220 (8.0) 0.45 Cesarean delivery 517 (10.0) 2714 (9.8) 0.63 Postpartum hemorrhage 209 (4.1) 1174 (4.3) 0.54 Third- and fourth-degree perineal laceration 67 (1.3) 411 (1.5) 0.31 5-min Apgar score < 7 22 (0.5) 156 (0.6) 0.30 Umbilical pH < 7.2 94 (20.3) 656 (23.3) 0.15 Prolonged second stage 127 (2.5%) 622 (2.3%) 0.36 Maternal and fetal composite adverse outcome* 852 (16.5%) 4676 (16.9%) 1.00 Data is presented as N (%) *Maternal and fetal composite adverse outcome was defined as the presence of any of the following: vacuum delivery, CD, prolonged second stage, postpartum hemorrhage, third and fourth degree perineal laceration, 5-min Apgar score < 7 and umbilical cord pH < 7.2 CONCLUSION: Nurses' shift change and on-call physicians' shift change does not appear to be associated with an increase in adverse maternal or neonatal outcomes.