Health Literacy and Decisional Preferences in Hand Surgery

Patients increasingly prefer to be involved in health decisions. Shared decisions are associated with less decisional conflict and improved satisfaction. This study examines the relationship between health literacy and preferred decision-making role in patients seeking care for hand problems.

We performed a cross-sectional study of 226 patients who were presenting to a hand service for the first time, who were older than 18 years, not pregnant, and fluent and literate in English. Patient demographic information, work status, and education level were collected from the patient. Diagnosis and insurance status were collected from the medical record. Pain interference, depression, and upper extremity function were measured using the Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System (PROMIS) questionnaires administered with computerized adaptive testing. Health literacy and preferred decision-making role were assessed using the Newest Vital Sign Test and Control Preference Scale, respectively. Discordance between preferred and actual decision-making role was assessed using the Control Preference Scale statements with the words "I prefer" omitted. Bivariate and multivariable logistic regressions were used to assess for factors associated with preferred decision-making role and discordance.

Seventy-eight percent of patients preferred an active or collaborative, rather than a passive, role in decision making. Sixty-one percent felt they had achieved their preferred role. Preferred role and achievement of that role were not associated with health literacy, age, race, insurance, work status, diagnosis, pain intensity, symptoms of depression, and magnitude of self-reported activity limitations. More years of education was associated with a more active preferred decision-making role but not with obtaining that preferred role.

Most people want to participate in decisions about their care even if they have low health literacy.

Hand specialists can seek strategies to help people understand and participate in care decisions.