Smoke-water commonly induces hormetic dose responses in plants

A detailed evaluation was made of the literature concerning the dose response features of smoke-water extracts and other types of biological pyrolysis products on seed germination and plant growth. The evaluation was undertaken to extend our research on the occurrence and importance of hormesis in plant biology, as no similar assessment on smoke water biology had been published and that a preliminary survey suggested widespread occurrence of hormesis. It was determined that hormetic-like biphasic dose responses were commonly reported within the smoke-water plant literature for seed germination and plant growth. These findings were independent of the type of plant evaluated, the type of plant material used for the smoke-water extract, and the process of pyrolysis and extraction. The magnitude of the maximal stimulation of the biphasic dose responses was consistent with the hormetic concept, with maximal responses typically being approximately 30-60% greater than control values and with a stimulatory dose/concentration width less than 10 fold. These findings, which represent dose response features of a spectrum of novel and chemically diverse complex mixtures, support the generality of the hormetic dose response and its potential utility in enhancing the quality of study designs, including selection of dose/concentration number and spacing as well as biological model and endpoint.