Related Experiment Video
Updated: Dec 4, 2025

A Guide to Concentration Alternating Frequency Response Analysis of Fuel Cells
Published on: December 11, 2019
Real-Time Estimation of Bare-Airframe Frequency Responses from Closed-Loop Data and Multisine Inputs
Jared A Grauer1, Matthew J Boucher2
1NASA Langley Research Center, Hampton, Virginia, 23681, Research Engineer, Dynamic Systems and Control Branch, MS 308, Associate Fellow AIAA.
This study introduces a new method for estimating aircraft frequency responses from flight data, even with complex control systems. The technique uses unique frequency excitations to accurately measure bare-airframe dynamics, improving flight analysis.
Area of Science:
- Aerospace Engineering
- Control Systems Theory
- System Identification
Background:
- Estimating bare-airframe dynamics from flight test data is challenging due to feedback control and control effector mixing.
- Existing methods may struggle to accurately isolate the airframe's inherent frequency responses in the presence of these complexities.
Purpose of the Study:
- To develop and validate a novel method for accurately estimating multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) bare-airframe frequency responses.
- To address the confounding effects of feedback control and control mixing in flight test data analysis.
Main Methods:
- Utilizing orthogonal phase-optimized multisines to simultaneously excite each input with unique harmonic frequencies.
- Computing frequency responses as ratios of output-to-input Fourier transform data at excitation frequencies.
- Resolving confounding effects of feedback and mixing through frequency response interpolation.
Main Results:
- The method successfully estimated frequency responses from simulated and real flight test data.
- Effectiveness verified on a T-2 generic transport airplane simulation with rate feedback.
- Demonstrated on the X-56A MUTT aeroelastic airplane with both feedback control and mixing.
Conclusions:
- The presented method provides an effective means for estimating MIMO bare-airframe frequency responses from flight data.
- The technique can be applied in both post-flight batch analysis and real-time flight analysis.
- Accurate estimation is achievable despite the presence of feedback control and control effector mixing.
Related Concept Videos
Linear Approximation in Frequency Domain
In contrast, nonlinear systems do not inherently possess these properties. However, for small deviations around an operating point, a nonlinear system can often be approximated as linear....
Frequency Response of a Circuit
The transfer function is pivotal in characterizing how these circuits react to various frequencies, facilitating a profound understanding of their behavior. An essential parameter is the time constant, signifying the...
Frequency Response of Op Amp Circuits
Frequency Response and Gain:
The gain of the op-amp, A(ω), is not a constant but a function of the input signal frequency. An op-amp can maintain a constant gain at low frequencies, known...
Transient and Steady-state Response
These test signals are integral in designing control systems to exhibit two key performance aspects: transient response and steady-state...
Multimachine Stability
In analyzing the system, the nodal equations represent the relationship between bus voltages, machine voltages, and machine currents. The nodal equation is given by:
Linear Approximation in Time Domain
For a simple pendulum with a mass evenly distributed along its length and the center of mass located at half the pendulum's length,...

