Polarity/charge as a determinant of translocase requirements for membrane protein insertion

The YidC insertase of Escherichia coli inserts membrane proteins with small periplasmic loops (~20 residues). However, it has difficulty transporting loops that contain positively charged residues compared to negatively charged residues and, as a result, increasing the positive charge has an increased requirement for the Sec machinery as compared to negatively charged loops (Zhu et al., 2013; Soman et al., 2014). This suggested that the polarity and charge of the periplasmic regions of membrane proteins determine the YidC and Sec translocase requirements for insertion. Here we tested this polarity/charge hypothesis by showing that insertion of our model substrate protein procoat-Lep can become YidC/Sec dependent when the periplasmic loop was converted to highly polar even in the absence of any charged residues. Moreover, adding a number of hydrophobic amino acids to a highly polar loop can decrease the Sec-dependence of the otherwise strictly Sec-dependent membrane proteins. We also demonstrate that the length of the procoat-Lep loop is indeed a determinant for Sec-dependence by inserting alanine residues that do not markedly change the overall hydrophilicity of the periplasmic loop. Taken together, the results support the polarity/charge hypothesis as a determinant for the translocase requirement for procoat insertion.