Related Experiment Video
Updated: Dec 2, 2025

Dynamic Monitoring of Seroconversion using a Multianalyte Immunobead Assay for Covid-19
Published on: February 16, 2022
Harmonizing Heterogeneous Endpoints in Coronavirus Disease 2019 Trials Without Loss of Information
Maja von Cube1,2, Marlon Grodd1,2, Martin Wolkewitz1,2
1Institute of Medical Biometry and Statistics, Faculty of Medicine and Medical Center, University of Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany.
Objectives:
Many trials investigate potential effects of treatments for coronavirus disease 2019. To provide sufficient information for all involveddecision-makers (clinicians, public health authorities, and drug regulatory agencies), a multiplicity of endpoints must be considered. The objectives are to provide hands-on statistical guidelines for harmonizing heterogeneous endpoints in coronavirus disease 2019 clinical trials.
Design:
Randomized controlled trials for patients infected with coronavirus disease 2019.
Setting:
General methods that apply to any randomized controlled trial for patients infected with coronavirus disease 2019.
Patients:
Coronavirus disease 2019 positive individuals.
Interventions:
None.
Measurements And Main Results:
We develop a multistate model that is based on hospitalization, mechanical ventilation, death, and discharge. These events are both categories of the ordinal endpoint recommended by the World Health Organization and also within the core outcome set of the Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials initiative for coronavirus disease 2019 trials. To support our choice of states in the multistate model, we also perform a brief review of registered coronavirus disease 2019 clinical trials. Based on the multistate model, we give recommendation for compact, informative illustration of time-dynamic treatment effects and explorative statistical analysis. A majority of coronavirus disease 2019 clinical trials collect information on mechanical ventilation, hospitalization, and death. Using reconstructed and real data of coronavirus disease 2019 trials, we show how a stacked probability plot provides a detailed understanding of treatment effects on the patients' course of hospital stay. It contributes to harmonizing multiple endpoints and differing lengths of follow-up both within and between trials.
Conclusions:
All ongoing clinical trials should include a stacked probability plot in their statistical analysis plan as descriptive analysis. While primary analysis should be on an early endpoint with appropriate capability to be a surrogate (parameter), our multistate model provides additional detailed descriptive information and links results within and between coronavirus disease 2019 trials.
Insights
This study offers statistical guidelines for harmonizing coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) trial endpoints. A multistate model and stacked probability plot help analyze treatment effects for better decision-making.
Area of Science:
- Statistics
- Clinical Trials
- Epidemiology
Background:
- Numerous clinical trials are investigating treatments for coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19).
- Effective decision-making by clinicians, public health authorities, and regulatory agencies requires comprehensive information from these trials.
- Harmonizing heterogeneous endpoints across COVID-19 trials is crucial for synthesizing evidence.
Purpose of the Study:
- To provide statistical guidelines for harmonizing diverse endpoints in COVID-19 clinical trials.
- To introduce a multistate model for analyzing patient outcomes.
- To recommend methods for illustrating time-dynamic treatment effects.
Main Methods:
- Development of a multistate model incorporating hospitalization, mechanical ventilation, death, and discharge.
- Review of registered COVID-19 clinical trials to support model state selection.
- Application of a stacked probability plot for visualizing treatment effects on patient hospital course.
Main Results:
- The multistate model effectively integrates key patient outcomes (hospitalization, ventilation, death, discharge).
- Stacked probability plots offer detailed insights into treatment effects on patient trajectories.
- The proposed methods facilitate the harmonization of multiple endpoints and varying follow-up durations.
Conclusions:
- Ongoing COVID-19 trials should incorporate stacked probability plots for descriptive analysis.
- The multistate model provides valuable descriptive information, linking results within and between trials.
- This approach aids in understanding treatment effects and harmonizing data for robust evidence synthesis.
Related Concept Videos
Clinical Trials: Overview
Bioequivalence studies: Biowaivers
Clinical Trials
There are four phases in a clinical trial. A phase one...
Bioavailability Study Design: Healthy Subjects Versus Patients
Bioequivalence of Drugs: Drugs with Multiple Indications
Bioequivalence Data: Statistical Interpretation

