The challenges of venoarterial extracorporeal membrane oxygenation for postcardiotomy cardiogenic shock

Postcardiotomy cardiogenic shock describes the syndrome of refractory cardiac performance following cardiac surgery. The use of venoarterial extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (VA-ECMO) for the management of postcardiotomy cardiogenic shock is controversial, and there are at least three scenarios where it may be necessary: first, pre-emptive postoperative VA-ECMO, where the decision for postoperative mechanical support is made prior to surgery, for example, in the context of poor pre-operative cardiac function; second, early yet unplanned post-cardiopulmonary bypass VA-ECMO following a long duration of cardiopulmonary bypass due to, for example, unexpected surgical complications; third, late rescue VA-ECMO following several attempts at weaning, either immediately following cardiopulmonary bypass or following transfer to the intensive care unit. The use of mechanical circulatory support for postcardiotomy cardiogenic shock is further complicated by the wide range of available devices, the availability of VA-ECMO in different centres, variations in experience and expertise as a function of local VA-ECMO workload, and regional variations in the diagnosis and management of postcardiotomy cardiogenic shock. Furthermore, survival appears to be low for such patients and it is not yet possible to predict who will survive. Many questions remain, however, such as those in relation to practices around patient selection, how best to study long-term outcomes, the ethics and efficacy of ECMO in such patients, and on all aspects of clinical decision-making. This review sets these clinical challenges in the context of the available evidence, including that from our centre.