State of Microsurgery Training in 2020: Survey of Hand Surgery Fellowship Program Directors

Given the current national conundrum of decreasing microsurgery case volume performed by hand surgery fellows despite interest, program directors were surveyed to evaluate opinions of exposure gaps in training and to determine the current state of microsurgery training in 2020.

Anonymous national surveys were distributed to hand surgery fellowship program directors by the American Society for Surgery of the Hand. Subgroups were compared by training location and size of the fellowship program. Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education public national data on graduate case log procedures by hand surgery fellows were reviewed.

Eighty-eight surveys were distributed by the American Society for Surgery of the Hand to hand surgery fellowship program directors with a 44% (n = 39) response rate. Hand surgery fellowship programs from 19 US states participated. Most program's fellows had previous orthopedic surgery residency training with 41.03% of programs surveyed having 100% orthopedic surgery-trained fellows. The average number of weekly vascular microsurgical cases ranged from 25% of fellowships having no microsurgery cases per week, 46.2% having 1 per week, and only 7.7% having 5 or more cases per week. However, 60.5% of program directors prioritized a microvascular surgery case as the most valuable educational opportunity for fellows. Most program directors agreed (79.5%) that a 1-year hand surgery fellowship is sufficient to train a competent hand surgeon, who is proficient in microsurgery. In contrast, the majority disagreed (53.8%) that hand surgery microsurgery skills after a 1-year hand surgery fellowship are equivalent among graduates, regardless of a prior plastic surgery or orthopedic surgery residency training. There was a statistically significant difference in program directors' responses by geographic location regarding prior residency background impacting microsurgical skills (Kendall τ, -0.439; P = 0.001). Graduate case log data revealed an increasing trend in the number of microsurgery procedures performed by orthopedic hand surgery fellows until 2014, with a decline in cases per year and stagnating trend at 7% thereafter.

In 2020, most hand surgery fellowship program directors highly value and prioritize microsurgery exposure for their hand surgery fellows' education despite the decrease in case volume for hand surgery fellows.