3D-CT stress test for the assessment of CFL insufficiency

Following ankle sprains, some patients complain of their ankles "giving way," characterized by functional instability with no positive findings in traditional stress tests. The calcaneofibular ligament (CFL) may contribute to the stabilization of the subtalar and talocrural joints, and some functional instability may be due to CFL insufficiency. We aimed to clarify and quantitatively assess CFL insufficiency with three-dimensional stress computer tomography (CT) using the Pronation-External Rotation Stress Test (PERST).

Ten patients who tested positive under PERST and underwent an isolated CFL reconstruction were included. Using a custom-made loading jig, we used the Supination-Internal Rotation Stress Test (SIRST) and PERST to assess the function of anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL) and CFL, respectively. 3D-CT in neutral position was used as a baseline, and we quantified the distance between the origin and insertion of the CFL and ATFL at 2 years pre- and postoperatively.

Postoperative scores improved in all patients with no giving way symptoms. The preoperative length of the CFL increased by 14.0% from baseline under PERST, while the postoperative length only increased by 2.0% and was significantly restricted (P < .01). The pre- and postoperative length of ATFL was increased by 7.5% and 9.0% from baseline under SIRST, respectively, with no significant difference (P = .41). The clinical function improved with significantly less change in distance between the origin and insertion under PERST and showed no difference under SIRST.

The 3D-CT stress test may be useful for quantifying pre- and postoperative CFL function. CFL insufficiency is one of the main causes of subtalar joint instability; therefore, measuring the distance between the origin and insertion of the CFL could provide the means to quantify the instability of the subtalar joint.