Overview of the SAMPL6 pK_a challenge: evaluating small molecule microscopic and macroscopic pK_a predictions

The prediction of acid dissociation constants (pK_a) is a prerequisite for predicting many other properties of a small molecule, such as its protein-ligand binding affinity, distribution coefficient (log D), membrane permeability, and solubility. The prediction of each of these properties requires knowledge of the relevant protonation states and solution free energy penalties of each state. The SAMPL6 pK_a Challenge was the first time that a separate challenge was conducted for evaluating pK_a predictions as part of the Statistical Assessment of Modeling of Proteins and Ligands (SAMPL) exercises. This challenge was motivated by significant inaccuracies observed in prior physical property prediction challenges, such as the SAMPL5 log D Challenge, caused by protonation state and pK_a prediction issues. The goal of the pK_a challenge was to assess the performance of contemporary pK_a prediction methods for drug-like molecules. The challenge set was composed of 24 small molecules that resembled fragments of kinase inhibitors, a number of which were multiprotic. Eleven research groups contributed blind predictions for a total of 37 pK_a distinct prediction methods. In addition to blinded submissions, four widely used pK_a prediction methods were included in the analysis as reference methods. Collecting both microscopic and macroscopic pK_a predictions allowed in-depth evaluation of pK_a prediction performance. This article highlights deficiencies of typical pK_a prediction evaluation approaches when the distinction between microscopic and macroscopic pK_as is ignored; in particular, we suggest more stringent evaluation criteria for microscopic and macroscopic pK_a predictions guided by the available experimental data. Top-performing submissions for macroscopic pK_a predictions achieved RMSE of 0.7-1.0 pK_a units and included both quantum chemical and empirical approaches, where the total number of extra or missing macroscopic pK_as predicted by these submissions were fewer than 8 for 24 molecules. A large number of submissions had RMSE spanning 1-3 pK_a units. Molecules with sulfur-containing heterocycles or iodo and bromo groups were less accurately predicted on average considering all methods evaluated. For a subset of molecules, we utilized experimentally-determined microstates based on NMR to evaluate the dominant tautomer predictions for each macroscopic state. Prediction of dominant tautomers was a major source of error for microscopic pK_a predictions, especially errors in charged tautomers. The degree of inaccuracy in pK_a predictions observed in this challenge is detrimental to the protein-ligand binding affinity predictions due to errors in dominant protonation state predictions and the calculation of free energy corrections for multiple protonation states. Underestimation of ligand pK_a by 1 unit can lead to errors in binding free energy errors up to 1.2 kcal/mol. The SAMPL6 pK_a Challenge demonstrated the need for improving pK_a prediction methods for drug-like molecules, especially for challenging moieties and multiprotic molecules.