Association Between Family Medicine Residents' Mindsets and In-Training Exam Scores

In medical practice, a mastery mindset is important for engaging in lifelong learning. The objective of this study was to examine the association between family medicine residents' scores on mindset measures and their performance on in-training examinations (ITE).

This was a secondary data analysis of a cohort of family medicine residents. Following ethics approval, residents' ITE scores from each of the 2 years of residency were linked with residents' responses to a mindsets survey that they had taken at the midpoint of residency training. Multiple regression analysis was used to investigate the relationship between residents' mindset scores and their ITE scores. Of 85 residents, 46 (54%) had complete data for the three data collection points.

Residents' ITE scores in year 1 were most predictive of their ITE scores in year 2 (β=0.72; P<.001). Mastery mindset scores were negatively associated with residents' performance on the ITE in year 2 (β=-0.29; P=.004).

While the observed negative relationship between residents' mastery mindset scores and their ITE performance may be disconcerting, it is not surprising. In clinical settings, residents are individually coached by preceptors and provided with specific, actionable feedback to support their learning. With respect to formative assessments, residents likely require explicit training on how to use their assessment results (ITE scores) to support their self-directed learning. This finding has practical implications for residency programs in using ITEs as formative assessments.