Nonapproximated third-order exchange induction energy in symmetry-adapted perturbation theory

The exchange terms in symmetry-adapted perturbation theory (SAPT) are normally calculated within the so-called S² or single exchange approximation, which approximates the all-electron antisymmetrizer by interchanges of at most one electron pair between the interacting molecules. This approximation is typically very accurate at the van der Waals minimum separation and at larger intermolecular distances but begins to deteriorate at short range. Nonapproximated expressions for the second-order SAPT exchange corrections have been derived some time ago by Schäffer and Jansen [Mol. Phys. 111, 2570 (2013)]. In this work, we extend Schäffer and Jansen's formalism to derive and implement a nonapproximated expression for the third-order exchange-induction correction. Numerical tests on several representative noncovalent databases show that the S² approximation underestimates the exchange-induction contributions in both second and third orders. This underestimation is very similar in relative terms, but the larger absolute values of the third-order exchange-induction effects, and their near complete cancellation with the corresponding induction energies, make the third-order errors more severe. In the worst-case scenario of interactions involving ions, the breakdown of the S² approximation can result in a qualitatively wrong, attractive character of SAPT total energies at short range {as first observed by Lao and Herbert [J. Phys. Chem. A 116, 3042 (2012)]}. As expected, the inclusion of the full third-order exchange-induction energy in place of its S²-approximated counterpart restores the correct, repulsive short-range behavior of the SAPT potential energy curves computed through the third order.