What's it Worth?: The Costs and Benefits of an Initiative to Decrease Post-Call Fatigued Driving Among Surgery...

In 2017 the ACGME enacted new regulations requiring sponsoring institutions to ensure "safe transportation options for residents who may be too fatigued to safely return home." We investigate here the impact of a pilot "Safe Ride" program designed to mitigate the risks of fatigued driving.

During a 2-month pilot period at a single university-affiliated general surgery residency with four urban clinical sites, all residents (n = 72) were encouraged to hire a rideshare (e.g., Uber, Lyft) to and from 24-h clinical shifts if they felt too fatigued to drive safely. The cost of the rideshare was fully reimbursed to the resident. The impact of this intervention was evaluated using utilization data and a post-intervention resident survey.

A total of 16.6% of trainees utilized a rideshare at least one time. Sixty-three post-call rides were taken, predominantly by junior residents (92.4%) and for commutes greater than 15 miles (91%). The cost for the 60-day pilot was $3030. Comparing pre-intervention to post-intervention data, there was a significant improvement in the reported frequency of falling asleep or nearly asleep while driving (P < 0.001). Trainees nearly unanimously (98%) supported efforts to make the program permanent.

Driving while fatigued is common among surgical residents, with increased risk among junior residents, during longer commutes and following longer shifts. A reimbursed rideshare program effectively targets these risk factors and was associated with a significant decrease in rates of self-reported fatigued driving. Future efforts should focus on strategies to promote use of reimbursed rideshare programs while remaining cost efficient.