Ecological hazard assessment via species sensitivity distributions: The non-exchangeability issue

Probabilistic approaches to hazard assessment use species sensitivity distributions (SSDs) to characterize hazard for toxicants exposure for different species within a community. Many of the assumptions at the core of SSDs are unrealistic, among them the assumption that the tolerance levels of all species in a specific ecological community are a priori exchangeable for each new toxic substance. Here we propose the use of a particular test to detect situations where such an assumption is violated. Then, a new method based on non-nested random effects model is required to identify novel SSDs capable of taking into account species non-exchangeability. Credible intervals, representing SSD uncertainty, could be determined based on our procedure. This leads to new and reliable estimates of the environmental hazard. We present a Bayesian modeling approach to address model inference issues, using Markov chain Monte Carlo sampling.