A review of reductionist methods in fish gastrointestinal tract physiology

A holistic understanding of a physiological system can be accomplished through the use of multiple methods. Our current understanding of the fish gastrointestinal tract (GIT) and its role in both nutrient handling and osmoregulation is the result of the examination of the GIT using multiple reductionist methods. This review summarizes the following methods: in vivo mass balance studies, and in vitro gut sac preparations, intestinal perfusions, and Ussing chambers. From Homer Smith's initial findings of marine fish intestinal osmoregulation in the 1930s through to today's research, we discuss the methods, their advantages and pitfalls, and ultimately how they have each contributed to our understanding of fish GIT physiology. Although in vivo studies provide substantial information on the intact animal, segment specific functions of the GIT cannot be easily elucidated. Instead, in vitro gut sac preparations, intestinal perfusions, or Ussing chamber experiments can provide considerable information on the function of a specific tissue and permit the delineation of specific transport pathways through the use of pharmacological agents; however, integrative inputs (e.g. hormonal and neuronal) are removed and only a fraction of the organ system can be studied. We conclude with two case studies, i) divalent cation transport in teleosts and ii) nitrogen handling in the elasmobranch GIT, to highlight how the use of multiple reductionist methods contributes to a greater understanding of the organ system as a whole.