Sonic hedgehog signals hinder the transcriptional network necessary for pancreatic endoderm formation from human embryonic stem cells

Hedgehog morphogens govern multiple aspects of pancreas organogenesis and functioning with diverse outcomes across species. Although most current differentiation protocols repress Sonic hedgehog (SHH) signals during in vitro endocrine specification, the role and mechanisms through which the SHH pathway antagonizes pancreas development during in vitro human embryonic stem (hES) cell differentiation remain unclear. We modulated SHH signaling at transitory stages of hES cell-derived pancreatic progenitors and analyzed the effect on cellular fate decisions. We identify the Hedgehog pathway as a negative regulator of pancreatic endoderm formation through up-regulation of a set of pancreatobiliary markers required for ductal specification, including SOX17, FOXA2, HNF1β, HNF6, PDX1, and SOX9. Surprisingly, active Hedgehog signals impeded a group of pancreatic epithelium markers, including HNF4α, HHEX, PAX6, and PTF1α. To understand how SHH signals repress the transcription of these specific markers, we analyzed Polycomb group proteins. We found differential expression of Polycomb Repressive Complex 1 subunit, BMI1 upon Shh pathway modulation in the pancreatic progenitors. Ectopic activation of Sonic hedgehog results in over-expression of BMI1 and its associated repressive histone mark, H2AK119Ub1, in the multipotent progenitors. Our data suggest that Sonic hedgehog restricts the pancreatic differentiation program by limiting progenitor cells acquiring pancreatic epithelial fates and instead promotes pancreatobiliary differentiation. We further provide mechanistic cues of an association between Hedgehog signaling and epigenetic silencers during pancreatic lineage decisions.