Coexistent Hoffmann reflexes in human leg muscles are commonly due to volume conduction

The existence of "concomitant" (coexistent) electromyographic reflex responses in soleus and tibialis anterior muscles, produced by posterior tibial nerve stimulation, has been cited as evidence for "reciprocal excitation" between these antagonistic muscles normally reflexly linked by reciprocal inhibition. Using the Hoffmann reflex procedure and posterior tibial nerve stimulation, the existence of true reciprocal excitation was tested in six subjects with no neuromuscular impairment. Coexistent EMG responses were observed in all subjects. In no instance, however, could the tibialis anterior EMG volley to posterior tibial nerve stimulation of the soleus muscle be antidromically blocked by common peroneal nerve stimulation applied at 10 to 20 ms offset latencies. A second stimulation pulse applied to the common peroneal nerve at similar offset latencies did antidromically block a tibialis anterior reflex response to common peroneal nerve stimulation. Therefore, volume conduction of reflex activity from the posterior tibial compartment to the anterior tibial compartment was a common observance. We suggest that coexistent EMG reflex responses, presumed to reflect reciprocal excitation, should be tested by the procedure described to reject the possibility of EMG cross-talk as a confounding variable or as the actual variable under investigation.