Inter-Reader Variability of Volumetric Subsolid Pulmonary Nodule Radiomic Features

To evaluate the inter-observer consistency for subsolid pulmonary nodule radiomic features.

Subsolid nodules were selected by reviewing radiology reports of CT examinations performed December 1, 2015 to April 1, 2016. Patients with CTs at two time points were included in this study. There were 55 patients with subsolid nodules, of whom 14 had two nodules. Of 69 subsolid nodules, 66 were persistent at the second time point, yielding 135 lesions for segmentation. Two thoracic radiologists and an imaging fellow segmented the lesions using a semi-automated volumetry algorithm (Syngo.via Vb20, Siemens). Coefficient of variation (CV) was used to assess consistency of 91 quantitative measures extracted from the subsolid nodule segmentations, including first and higher order texture features. The accuracy of segmentation was visually graded by an experienced thoracic radiologist. Influencing factors on radiomic feature consistency and segmentation accuracy were assessed using generalized estimating equation analyses and the Exact Mann-Whitney test.

Mean patient age was 71 (38-93 years), with 39 women and 16 men. Mean nodule volume was 1.39mL, range .03-48.2mL, for 135 nodules. Several radiomic features showed high inter-reader consistency (CV<5%), including entropy, uniformity, sphericity, and spherical disproportion. Descriptors such as surface area and energy had low consistency across inter-reader segmentations (CV>10%). Nodule percent solid component and attenuation influenced inter-reader variability of some radiomic features. The presence of contrast did not significantly affect the consistency of subsolid nodule radiomic features. Near perfect segmentation, within 5% of actual nodule size, was achieved in 68% of segmentations, and very good segmentation, within 25% of actual nodule size, in 94%. Morphologic features including nodule margin and shape (each p <0.01), and presence of air bronchograms (p = 0.004), bubble lucencies (p = 0.02) and broad pleural contact (p < 0.01) significantly affected the probability of near perfect segmentation. Stroke angle (p = 0.001) and length (p < 0.001) also significantly influenced probability of near perfect segmentation.

The inter-observer consistency of radiomic features for subsolid pulmonary nodules varies, with high consistency for several features, including sphericity, spherical disproportion, and first and higher order entropy, and normalized non-uniformity. Nodule morphology influences the consistency of subsolid nodule radiomic features, and the accuracy of subsolid nodule segmentation.