A closed- versus open-set measure of speech discrimination in normally hearing young and elderly adults

This investigation sought to determine whether the pattern of performance differed between young and elderly normally hearing adults on a closed v. open-set discrimination task. The California Consonant Test was administered at 32 dB SL (re:SRT) to 20 young and 20 elderly normally hearing subjects under two conditions: one which required subjects to mark their response on a multiple choice answer form; and a second which required subjects to provide a one-word written response on a blank answer form. The only significant difference occurred within the young group between conditions (closed-set, open-set). The young group's speech discrimination was significantly better in the closed-set condition then in the open-set condition. No other differences were significant. The results question the concept of phonemic regression as a concomitant of ageing.