Human Cell-Based in vitro Phenotypic Profiling for Drug Safety-Related Attrition

Ensuring the safety of new drugs is critically important to regulators, pharmaceutical researchers and patients alike. Even so, unexpected toxicities still account for 20-30% of clinical trial failures, in part due to the persistence of animal testing as the primary approach for de-risking new drugs. Clearly, improved methods for safety attrition that incorporate human-relevant biology are needed. This recognition has spurred interest in non-animal alternatives or new approach methodologies (NAMs) including in vitro models that utilize advances in the culture of human cell types to provide greater clinical relevance for assessing risk. These phenotypic assay systems use human primary and induced pluripotent stem cell-derived cells in various formats, including co-cultures and advanced cellular systems such as organoids, bioprinted tissues, and organs-on-a-chip. Despite the promise of these human-based phenotypic approaches, adoption of these platforms into drug discovery programs for reducing safety-related attrition has been slow. Here we discuss the value of large-scale human cell-based phenotypic profiling for incorporating human-specific biology into the de-risking process. We describe learnings from our experiences with human primary cell-based assays and analysis of clinically relevant reference datasets in developing in vitro-based toxicity signatures. We also describe how Adverse Outcome Pathway (AOP) frameworks can be used to integrate results from diverse platforms congruent with weight-of-evidence approaches from risk assessment to improve safety-related decisions in early discovery.