Microstructural responses of Zirconia materials to in-situ SEM nanoindentation

Development of optimal shaping processes for pre-sintered and sintered zirconia materials requires a fundamental understanding of damage and deformation mechanisms at small-scale contacts with diamond tools. This paper reports on responses of zirconia materials with distinct microstructures to nanoindentation associated with diamond machining using a Berkovich diamond indenter. In-situ nanoindentation was performed in a scanning electron microscope (SEM) and in-process filmed to record small contact events. Indentation morphology was SEM-mapped at high-magnifications. Although both pre-sintered porous and sintered dense zirconia materials mechanically revealed the quasi-plastic behavior in indentation, there were distinct responses of the two materials to quasi-plasticity at the microstructural level. For pre-sintered porous zirconia, the quasi-plasticity was attributed to shear faults resulting from breaking pore networks as microstructurally discrete interfaces, to lead to compression, fragmentation, pulverization and microcracking of zirconia crystals in indentation imprints. In contrast, sintered dense zirconia had shear band-induced quasi-plastic deformation, accompanied with localized tensile microfracture. A material index associated with the mechanical properties ranked the lower quasi-plasticity for pre-sintered porous zirconia than its sintered dense state, predicting more machining-induced damage in the former than the latter. Significantly higher indentation imprint volumes induced in indented pre-sintered porous zirconia than sintered dense state previses higher machining efficiency for the former than the latter. The microstructure-dependent indentation mechanisms provide the fundamental knowledge into micromechanics of abrasive machining of zirconia materials and may lead to a new microstructural design for zirconia materials to achieve a balanced machining efficiency and damage control.