Pulmonary carcinomas arising in association with scar: Cytomorphologic features in histologically confirmed cases

Lung carcinoma arising in association with scar tissue is a well-reported but much debated phenomenon. Scar tissue complicates imaging and pathologic tumor measurement for cancer staging. To the best of our knowledge, the cytological findings in lung scar carcinoma (LSC) have not been described in the literature. Therefore, the aim of this study was to characterize the findings in fine-needle aspirations (FNA) from histologically confirmed LSCs.

LSCs were identified on retrospective search. Cases with preoperative FNA material were reviewed, including non-scar cases that were used for comparison. The clinical and histopathology findings were recorded.

Twenty-seven cases associated with scar tissue had material for review and 35 cases not associated with scar tissue were used for comparison. The proportion of fibrosis in resection specimens ranged from 10% to 80%. Five (19%) FNA cases were hypocellular. There was no statistically significant difference between the scar and non-scar groups in terms of overall cellularity and diagnostic categories (P = .113 and P = .17, respectively). There was correlation between cytology and dominant pattern on histology in 19 (79%) adenocarcinoma cases. Spindle cells and fibrous or fibroelastotic fragments were present in 22 (81%) cases.

This is the first study describing the cytology associated with LSCs. The presence of fibrosis did not adversely impact cellularity, which is likely due to multiple excursions and selective microdissection of tumor cells by the FNA needle. The cytomorphological and histological patterns correlated in most cases. FNA is able to provide a preoperative diagnosis of carcinoma despite the presence of fibrosis.