Deep brain stimulation outcomes in the malignant end of Parkinson's disease spectrum

Heterogeneity of Parkinson's Disease (PD) phenotype may influence deep brain stimulation (DBS) outcome. However, DBS response in the malignant end of the PD spectrum has been poorly investigated.

To evaluate and compare DBS outcomes in malignant and benign PD patients, defined according to motor and non-motor symptom presentation at the presurgical selection.

We categorized a cohort of 154 parkinsonian patients fulfilling criteria for subthalamic nucleus (STN)-DBS into malignant, benign, and intermediate subtypes, according to a recently validated clinical PD classification. DBS efficacy on daily living independence (Schwab and England -S&E-score ≥70%), motor symptoms, and motor fluctuations (Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale -UPDRS- part-III and -IV, and Ambulatory Capacity Measure) were compared between malignant and benign patients, using corrected binary logistic regressions and repeated measure general linear model.

One year after surgery, the probability of losing daily life independence was 16-fold higher in malignant patients, even after adjusting for age at PD onset, PD duration, and percentage of motor improvement after STN-DBS (OR: 16.233; p: 0.035). Conversely, malignant and benign patients showed a similar extent of improvement after STN-DBS (p > 0.05) in motor symptoms, motor fluctuations, and ambulatory capacity, both in medication-ON and medication-OFF conditions.

DBS candidates in the malignant end of the PD spectrum may profit from a similar improvement of motor symptoms and fluctuations after STN-DBS when compared to benign PD. However, patients of the malignant group have a lower probability of maintaining independence in daily life early after surgery.