SPA: Single patient acceleration in oncology dose-escalation trials

Efficient identification of the optimal dose and dosing scheme is one of the most critical and challenging tasks in early-phase oncology trials. The results are far-reaching because advancing a sub-optimal dose to late-stage development may not only jeopardize patients' safety or fail to deliver desired efficacy, but also be costly to sponsors as refined doses must be evaluated further before seeking regulatory approval. A good dose-escalation design is anticipated to yield high accuracy of selecting the correct dose while using fewer patients and keeping the trial duration short. Recently, treating a single patient at each lower dose level until certain events are triggered to switch to larger cohorts has gained much popularity. We name this approach "Single Patient Acceleration" (SPA), which is essentially a variant of the Accelerated Titration Design (ATD) by Simon et al. [25]. Although literature on novel dose-escalation methods is abundant in the past decade, there is a surprisingly lack of research on evaluating the ATD/SPA framework. In this article, we conduct comprehensive simulations to evaluate the performance of dose-escalation designs with or without SPA, and show that SPA improves design efficiency with similar or better accuracy to those without the "single patient" component under certain circumstances (e.g., slow initial enrollment, or the true maximum tolerated dose is at higher candidate dose levels). Potential safety concerns as a cost of efficiency improvement are also investigated in a quantitative manner to illustrate a comprehensive benefit-risk profile of SPA. Practical considerations and recommendations in using SPA are also discussed.