Physeal Fractures of Distal Tibia: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

Fractures involving the distal tibia growth plate are common in children. Injury or treatment that damages the growth plate may result in progressive angular deformity or leg length discrepancy. There is no consensus on treatment and follow-up of these injuries. This study aims to describe which factors increase the risk of premature physeal closure (PPC).

A systematic review and meta-analysis were performed. Altogether 395 articles were reviewed, and ultimately 12 of them were found eligible, comprising 1997 patients. The most usual type of fracture was Salter-Harris (SH) II (n=855, 49%) followed by SH III (n=296, 17%) and SH I (n=261, 15%). The risk of PPC according to number of reduction attempts, method of treatment, and residual displacement was the primary outcome.

The total rate of PPC was 13% (n=245). The PPC rate varied from 0.2% to 42% across the studies. Patients with SH IV fractures were most likely to develop PPC (20%), followed by those with SH II (12%) (P<0.05) and repeated (>2) reduction maneuvers were associated with a higher risk of PPC (pooled odds ratio, 8.5; 95% confidence interval, 6.3-12.17; P<0.05). Open reduction was associated with a lower risk of PPC when analyzing only displaced fractures (odds ratio, 0.63; 95% confidence interval, 0.38-0.91; P<0.05).

This meta-analysis implies that residual displacement after reduction is the most significant factor in predicting PPC. It seems that open reduction might reduce the PPC rate among patients with dislocated fractures. In addition, there is some evidence that a higher number of reduction attempts correlates positively with the risk of PPC.